Bank Guarantee vs Letter of Credit in Commodity Trade: Which One Solves Which Problem
← All insights

Bank Guarantee vs Letter of Credit in Commodity Trade: Which One Solves Which Problem

By

Bienrock helps commodity trading companies choose and prepare the right bank instruments and approach suitable institutions for trade finance. We support deal structuring, documentation and bank selection; approval and terms remain the financial institution’s decision.

Key takeaways

  • A letter of credit is a payment instrument. In the normal course of the deal, the bank pays the seller when compliant documents are presented.
  • A bank guarantee, and a standby letter of credit used in the same way, is a backup instrument. It pays only when the beneficiary makes a demand, typically because the other party has failed to perform.
  • A letter of credit always protects the seller’s payment. A guarantee can protect either side: the buyer against non-delivery or a lost advance, or the seller against non-payment.
  • In commodity trade, the guarantees that come up most often are performance guarantees, advance payment guarantees and payment guarantees.
  • Many commodity deals use both instruments at once, each covering a different risk at a different stage of the contract.
  • Bienrock is not a bank. The financial institution decides whether to issue any instrument and on what terms.

Introduction

A grain buyer asks for a bank guarantee. The seller proposes a letter of credit instead. The two sides spend a week negotiating which instrument to use, as if they were interchangeable versions of the same promise.

They are not. Both can be issued by the same bank for the same cargo and still do opposite jobs. One is how the seller expects to get paid. The other is a safety net both parties hope will never be used.

The question is not which instrument is stronger. It is which risk each one is meant to cover. When a company asks for the wrong instrument, it either pays for protection it does not need or leaves the real risk uncovered.

This post covers what each instrument actually does, how the parties and the payment trigger differ, the guarantee types that come up most often in commodity trade, and an illustrative grain contract that uses both.

What Each Instrument Actually Means

A letter of credit is a bank’s undertaking to pay the seller, provided the seller presents documents that comply with the credit’s terms. The buyer asks its bank to issue it, and the seller is the beneficiary. Commercial letters of credit are commonly issued subject to UCP 600, the ICC’s rules for documentary credits. The credit is separate from the sales contract, and the bank examines documents, not goods. When the seller ships and presents compliant documents, payment follows as a normal step in the deal.

A bank guarantee is a bank’s undertaking to pay the beneficiary a sum of money if the beneficiary makes a demand that meets the guarantee’s terms. The demand usually states that the other party, the applicant, has failed to meet an obligation under the underlying contract. In international trade, banks usually issue guarantees as independent undertakings, separate from the contract they relate to. The guarantor bank checks the demand against the guarantee wording; it does not investigate who is right in the commercial dispute.

A standby letter of credit (SBLC) sits between the two. It takes the form of a letter of credit but works like a guarantee: it is drawn on only if something goes wrong. The choice between a standby and a guarantee is often a matter of market custom, the banks involved and the beneficiary’s preference: standbys are more common in the Americas, demand guarantees in Europe, Asia and the Middle East. What governs any specific instrument is its wording, the international rules it names (usually URDG 758 for demand guarantees, ISP98 or UCP 600 for standbys) and the applicable law.

The Core Difference: What Triggers Payment

Everything else follows from one distinction.

A letter of credit pays because the deal went right. The seller ships, presents the required documents and, if the presentation complies, the bank pays. Payment is the expected outcome, not an exception.

A guarantee pays because the deal went wrong. The beneficiary makes a demand, typically with a statement that the applicant has failed to deliver, perform or pay. If the demand complies with the guarantee’s terms, the bank pays. In a healthy contract, the guarantee expires without ever being drawn.

Under a letter of credit, the seller’s main risk is its own documents: a discrepancy or a late presentation can delay payment even when the cargo is perfect, as covered in our guide to letter of credit documents and rejection. Under a guarantee, the applicant’s main risk is the beneficiary’s demand. Because the bank looks at the demand, not the facts behind it, a guarantee can be called even when the applicant believes it has performed.

A letter of credit is an instrument the seller has to work for. A guarantee is an instrument the applicant has to live with.

How the Parties Differ

Parties in a letter of credit

The applicant is always the buyer and the beneficiary is always the seller. The buyer’s bank issues the credit; an advising bank, usually in the seller’s country, passes it on; and a confirming bank may add its own undertaking when the seller does not want the risk of the issuing bank or its country. The direction never changes: the credit moves the buyer’s payment risk onto a bank, for the seller’s benefit.

Parties in a bank guarantee

  • Applicant (sometimes called the principal): the party whose obligation is being backed, either the seller or the buyer, depending on the guarantee type.
  • Beneficiary: the party protected if the applicant fails to perform.
  • Guarantor: the bank that issues the guarantee and pays on a complying demand.
  • Counter-guarantor, in indirect structures: when the beneficiary wants a guarantee from a bank in its own country, the applicant’s bank may issue a counter-guarantee to a local bank, which then issues the guarantee.

The direction is what changes. A letter of credit only ever protects the seller’s payment. A guarantee protects whoever is exposed to the other party’s failure. A buyer that pays an advance needs protection from the seller. A seller that ships on open account needs protection from the buyer.

What both mean for the applicant’s bank

For the issuing bank, both are credit decisions. The bank takes on an obligation and relies on its customer to reimburse it, so either instrument usually uses part of the customer’s credit limits, and a bank may ask for collateral or a cash margin, especially from a company without an established trade finance relationship.

Typical Guarantees in Commodity Trade

Three guarantee types come up again and again. They are described here at a general level; what each one covers depends on its wording.

Performance guarantee

A performance guarantee backs the seller’s obligation to deliver as agreed: the right quantity, of the contracted quality, within the shipment period. It is issued at the seller’s request in favor of the buyer, and is usually set at a percentage of the contract value rather than the full amount.

It answers the buyer’s question: what happens if the seller does not ship? It gives a defined amount the buyer can call without first winning a dispute.

Advance payment guarantee

When the buyer pays part of the price before shipment, it takes the risk that the seller keeps the money and does not deliver. An advance payment guarantee covers that risk. The seller’s bank undertakes to repay the advance on the buyer’s demand if the seller fails to perform.

It is often drafted to become effective only once the advance is received, and to reduce as goods are shipped. Both points have to be written into the guarantee; neither applies automatically.

Payment guarantee

A payment guarantee backs the buyer’s obligation to pay. It is issued at the buyer’s request in favor of the seller. If the buyer does not pay on the due date, the seller can demand payment from the bank.

This is where the two instruments are most often confused. Under a letter of credit, the bank pays the seller against documents as the normal route. Under a payment guarantee, the buyer pays on open account as the normal route, and the seller calls the guarantee only if the buyer defaults. It often suits established relationships with repeat shipments, where both sides want to avoid presenting a full document set for every cargo.

Which Instrument Solves Which Problem

The practical question is not “guarantee or letter of credit?” but “whose risk, at which stage?”

  1. The seller does not want to ship before payment is secure, and the buyer is new or in a riskier market. A letter of credit, confirmed if the issuing bank or its country is a concern.
  2. The buyer is paying an advance and needs to recover it if the cargo never ships. An advance payment guarantee from the seller’s bank.
  3. The buyer needs assurance that the seller will perform at all. A performance guarantee, typically for a percentage of the contract value.
  4. The parties trade regularly on open account, but the seller wants a backstop against non-payment. A payment guarantee or a standby letter of credit from the buyer’s bank.

Two mismatches are common. A seller that accepts a payment guarantee instead of a letter of credit has accepted open account terms with a backstop: the buyer pays, not the bank, unless the buyer defaults. And a letter of credit does nothing for a buyer whose real concern is that the seller will take an advance and not deliver.

An Illustrative Grain Contract Using Both

The example below is hypothetical. The companies, quantities and percentages are illustrative and do not describe any real transaction, client or market practice on a specific route.

  • Seller: a hypothetical grain exporter.
  • Buyer: a hypothetical feed producer that has not traded with the seller before.
  • Cargo: an illustrative bulk shipment of feed corn, CIF the buyer’s port.
  • Payment terms: an illustrative 10% advance on signing, with the 90% balance by an irrevocable letter of credit available at sight.

The buyer’s concern is the advance, paid weeks before loading to a seller it does not know. So the contract requires an advance payment guarantee for the same amount, issued by the seller’s bank in favor of the buyer, effective once the advance arrives and expiring shortly after the latest shipment date. If the seller does not ship, the buyer can demand the advance back from the seller’s bank.

The seller’s concern is the balance. The letter of credit, issued by the buyer’s bank and, in this illustration, confirmed by a bank in the seller’s region, moves that risk to the banks: once the cargo is loaded and compliant documents are presented, the seller is paid. How such a credit runs from contract to payment is walked through in our post on letters of credit for grain trade.

Neither instrument replaces the other. The guarantee protects the buyer between paying the advance and shipment; the letter of credit protects the seller between loading and payment. Drop the guarantee, and the buyer carries the advance risk alone. Drop the credit, and the seller ships on trust.

After a few successful cargoes, the parties might move the balance to open account, backed by a payment guarantee or standby from the buyer’s bank. Whether that is acceptable depends on the seller’s view of the buyer; whether it is available depends on the buyer’s bank.

What to Check Before Agreeing to Either Instrument

The wording decides how an instrument behaves. These points are worth agreeing in the sales contract, before anyone applies to a bank:

  • Amount, currency and reduction as goods are shipped, where relevant.
  • Expiry. A guarantee without a clear expiry date or event keeps the applicant’s credit limits tied up and its exposure open.
  • Effectiveness, for example only after the advance is received.
  • Demand conditions. What the beneficiary must state or present to call a guarantee.
  • Issuing bank and location, including whether the beneficiary needs a local bank through a counter-guarantee or confirmation.
  • Governing rules and law, and consistency of dates, amounts and parties with the sales contract.

Treat unusual instrument offers with caution. Offers to “lease” or “monetize” guarantees or standby letters of credit outside a company’s own banking relationships are a known warning sign. A genuine instrument is issued by a bank on its own customer’s instructions, after a credit decision.

This is not legal advice. Guarantee wording can have legal consequences that differ by jurisdiction, and a specialist should review significant instruments.

How Bienrock Supports Commodity Trade Finance

Bienrock is a consulting company based in Geneva, Switzerland. It is not a bank, does not hold client funds and does not issue, confirm or finance letters of credit or guarantees itself. It acts as an intermediary between trading companies and financial institutions, and its trade finance work covers grain trading.

The work starts with a free 30-minute consultation on the commodity, the counterparties, the route and the risks the contract needs to cover. From there, Bienrock helps the company work out which instruments the deal actually needs, prepares the company and transaction documentation that institutions expect, and introduces the case to suitable institutions from a network of 200+ banking partners across Switzerland, the UK, the EU, the UAE, Singapore, Hong Kong, Turkey and Africa.

  • Full disclosure. The case is presented as it is, including counterparties, route and ownership.
  • Decision-makers, not front desks. Cases go to people who can assess commodity trade finance.
  • Pre-qualification first. Institutions are approached only where the case fits, which protects the company’s application history.

Whether to issue a letter of credit or a guarantee, and the limits, collateral, pricing and conditions, remain the financial institution’s decision.

FAQ

What is the main difference between a bank guarantee and a letter of credit? The payment trigger. A letter of credit pays the seller against compliant documents as the normal way the deal is settled. A bank guarantee pays the beneficiary only on a complying demand, usually after the other party has failed to perform.

Is a standby letter of credit the same as a bank guarantee? In function, they are very close. Both are backup instruments drawn on only when something goes wrong. They differ in form and in the rules they are usually issued under, and the choice often depends on market custom and the banks involved.

Which is better for a grain seller: a letter of credit or a payment guarantee? It depends on the buyer. With a new counterparty or a riskier market, a letter of credit gives the seller payment from a bank against documents. With an established buyer on open account, a payment guarantee can give a backstop with less paperwork per shipment.

Does Bienrock issue bank guarantees or letters of credit? No. Bienrock is not a bank. It helps grain trading companies prepare their case and introduces it to suitable institutions, which decide whether to issue an instrument and on what terms.

Conclusion

A letter of credit and a bank guarantee are not two versions of the same protection. A letter of credit is how a seller gets paid when the deal goes right. A guarantee is what a buyer or seller can call on when the deal goes wrong. Many commodity contracts need both, each covering a different party at a different stage.

Deciding which risk needs covering before choosing the instrument avoids paying for protection that sits on the wrong side of the deal.

If your company trades grain and needs to structure letters of credit or guarantees for a contract, start with a case assessment at bienrock.ch.

In this article
← Explore more insights

Essential — always active: website operation, security and remembering your choice.

You can use the website and contact us without accepting analytics.

Privacy Policy